“The RTI has started its journey, but is far from its destination.”

Paper-2: Significant issues in Indian Administration | UPSC PYQ - 2019

“The RTI has started its journey, but is far from its destination.”

In view of the statement, examine the present status of the RTI movement. 10 Marks (2019) - Paper-II

Suggested Outline for the above question:

Introduction

• Explain the objective of the RTI act. [Or]

• You can start with a fact → “At 1.33 million, RTI pleas in 2020-21 see a dip of only 2.9%” [Or]

• Use a relevant quote like the below one

“It is the first responsibility of every citizen to question authority” said Benjamin Franklin.

Body of the Answer

The question has asked to examine the given statement. Hence you must share both the positive and negative aspects to bring about a holistic perspective.

Use sub-headings that are linked to the wording of the question.

Benefits through the Introduction of RTI (expand on the below dimensions)

• Accountability -

• Transparency -

• Control Corruption -

• Improve Governance -

• Strengthening Democracy -

Challenges in reaching the Destination of the RTI movement

• Composition: Mostly retired bureaucrats.

• Lack of enforcement of the penalty for delays.

• Blackmailing/Murder of RTI Activists → Mention relevant examples here.

• Gender disparity in RTI usage

• Urban-local divide in RTI filing → Lack of awareness

Value Added points

• Master-Servant Relationship → Citizen is the master.

• Jan Sunavayyi experiment of MKSS in Rajasthan.

• International Dimension - When did the US, UK, and Sweden pass similar acts?

Conclusion

• Transparency is the norm and Secrecy is the exception.

• All the information available to the state should be automatically available to the Citizens

Use the above structure and share your answer in the comments below. Brainstorm on the relevant examples for this topic or additional dimensions that can be added.